My latest essay entitled “New Confusion on Washington’s Intentions” has stirred up controversy. There were numerous comments on both of my websites and also direct emails to me on the subject. Among the remarks was the following, which surely invites a delving deeper into the matter:
“It is inconceivable that the Kremlin would agree to Ukraine in NATO under any feasible circumstance.”
As I stated in my essay, the Russian position has been set out very clearly on numerous occasions: Ukraine must be restored to the neutral status that was enshrined in its constitution when it became an independent state following the break-up of the Soviet Union. Per President Putin, there must be no foreign troops or military installations on Ukrainian soil.
However, this position from the first days of the Special Military Operation has not taken into account the very important changes in Europe’s intentions for its defense ever since President Trump put in doubt the readiness of the U.S.A. to come to its defense under the terms of NATO’s Article 5. That was put in doubt already in his first term when he made American military aid contingent on the Member States raising their military expenditures to specific percentages of their GDP. Then at the very start of Trump’s second term there was his readiness to go to war against the NATO member state Denmark over possession of Greenland. That made a mockery of the whole concept of the Alliance. And finally, there was Trump’s cut-off of U.S. supplied military hardware to Ukraine free of charge: it would continue only if the Europeans placed orders and paid for such shipments out of their own pockets, and it would be limited by the depleted American arsenals due to the Iran war.
The net result of all of these words and actions by Donald Trump was to prompt a constellation of leading European states, all members of the Coalition of the Willing hardline backers of Ukraine to enter into an informal defense alliance outside of NATO. And while my peers in Alternative Media daily celebrate the death of NATO (prematurely in the Mark Twain sense), none seem to be paying attention to the parallel development of what is becoming a formidable fighting force in conventional warfare terms that is totally outside U.S. control. These are the Europe 5 (France, Germany, Italy, Poland and the U.K.) that intend to represent the Continent at the next round of Russia-Ukraine-USA talks, together with representatives of the European Institutions (Commission and Council). You will find detailed articles on what their cooperative remilitarization means in practice on the pages of The Financial Times, Bloomberg and other Mainstream news purveyors.
Put in this new context, it might well appear to the Kremlin that Ukraine in a U.S.-led NATO is preferable to Ukraine linked to the European hotheads who foment war fever to stay in power. This is all the more so if the NATO that emerges from the revision of European security architecture overseen by Trump and Putin is de-fanged, meaning that it pulls back men and materiel from their present forward positions, directly threatening Russia, to their boundaries of 1997, i.e., before the NATO expansion that began in the second term of Bill Clinton
©Gilbert Doctorow, 2026